Spiritual Health challenges the wellbeing narrative – but does it go deep enough?

3CP3X5W

Rachel Bedford’s new book offers valuable insight into why contemporary soul care can leave the already-exhausted even more exhausted. But as warm and carefully written as it is, it does not give adequate weight to suffering and trauma, says our reviewer

Bedford has written a work of popular pastoral theology. Her case is clean: the wellbeing conversation has expanded from bodies to minds and then stopped. We are body, mind and soul, yet the third has been left out of a national obsession with wellness. Her sharpest formulation is that Jesus never promised rest for bodies and minds, only for souls. Less wellness, more steadfastness. Sixteen short chapters run from what a soul is, through prayer, church, communion and scripture, to tradition, money, heaven and vocation.

In chapter four, Bedford notes that the spirituality shelf in Waterstones sits alongside self-help, and that the adjacency is not accidental. Contemporary soul care asks the exhausted to heal themselves, and the effort required is exactly what the exhausted do not have. That is a genuinely good observation about a human-centred spirituality, made without condescension towards the people buying those books.