A female Jesus? Christians are right to be offended
By 
Kate Orson2025-03-04T14:14:00
Grammy award-winning British actor, Cynthia Erivo, will become the first woman to play Jesus in a major production of Jesus Christ Superstar. Kate Orson says the decision is blasphemous, but Christians should take care in expressing themselves
See here for an alternative perspective on this story
Actress and singer Cynthia Erivo has been cast in the role of Jesus in the Hollywood Superbowl production of the musical Jesus Christ Superstar which will be performed in Los Angeles this summer.
Many Christians have already taken to social media to express dismay at the casting, considering it blasphemy, and I agree with them.
Jesus Christ Superstar has been controversial since its debut in 1971. Christians have long objected to the musical’s portrayal of Jesus as an imperfect human rather than the perfect son of God. There is also an implied romance between Jesus and Mary Magdalene, and Judas is depicted sympathetically. Billy Graham once described it as “bordering on blasphemy and sacrilege”.
The musical was never purported to be a faithful rendering of the Gospel story, so we perhaps shouldn’t expect it to be. However, casting a woman in the role of Jesus is a step too far, and I can’t help thinking it’s a deliberate act to mock God.
Christians are right to be upset about this. In previous decades there would be a certain reverence and respect for…
Related articles
-
ReviewsInside the Cult of the Jesus Army is a sensitive portrayal of the pain of abuse
Focusing on former members as they unpack the trauma inflicted by years of coercion, control and abuse within the Jesus Army, a new BBC documentary lays bare the grim reality the cult managed to mask for decades. Watching it, Tim Wyatt says, there’s little to do but weep with them
-
OpinionI’m so over the Christian hot take. Here’s 5 ways to respond
The internet is awash with Christians posting character assassinations of other Christians, says Max Avard. If you have a problem with Bethel Church or wish Brandon Lake had not collaborated with Jelly Roll, perhaps a 60 second video on social media is not the answer. Here’s some suggestions to help us do better
-
Magazine FeaturesWe don’t have to panic about the darkness in culture. I love heavy metal and I love Jesus
In the wake of Ozzy Osbourne’s death, Josh Hinton reflects on his introduction to heavy metal, his father’s passionate rejection of it, and why Christians shouldn’t fully separate themselves from the culture due to its darker edges — arguing that faith and heavy metal may be more compatible than we think
More from Opinion
-
OpinionHelp! I'm a Christian entrepreneur who uses AI...but should I?
The possibilities presented to us by Artificial Intelligence are many and varied, says Jean Kabasomi. But the technology also presents many questions and conflicts. In this open letter to the Church, she urges leaders to be proactive in helping their flock navigate it’s use wisely
-
OpinionHere’s a logical, biblical and pastoral response to Kemi Badenoch’s crisis of faith
In the face of evil and suffering, is belief in God still morally justifiable? No, says Kemi Badenoch who last week admitted losing her Christian faith following the revelations of Josef Fritzl’s crimes. In this response, Andrew Ollerton says that rejecting God because of evil is to saw off the very branch we are sitting on
-
OpinionThe Christian guide to dating apps
How can Christians approach online dating while staying true to their faith and values? Deborah Adelodun explores the pros and cons of five of the most popular dating apps available today
- Issues
- Topics A-Z
- Writers A-Z
- © 2025 Premier Christianity
Site powered by Webvision Cloud