Why I think The Chosen got it wrong with the Ramah scene
By 
Dr Andrew Ollerton2025-02-24T10:55:00
A shocking plot twist in the multi-season portrayal of the life of Jesus has upset some fans. Dr Andrew Ollerton explains why he’s concerned about the theological implications of The Chosen’s latest creative decision
During the long, dark, winter lockdown, our family began watching The Chosen.
From the first episode, we, like millions of others, were hooked.
Up to that point, I’d never really appreciated dramatisations of the Bible. But finally, here was a portrayal of Jesus I could believe in, along with disciples who had character and intrigue.
The whole production is world class and has set a new standard in visualisation (turning ancient accounts into fully dramatised scenes), harmonisation (blending four gospels into one compelling story) and adaptation (creating backstories and subplots to sustain a multi-season show).
Different episodes sparked great conversations with our children about whether something really happened, and if that’s what a Pharisee really looked like. As someone passionate about growing Bible engagement, I’ve been so grateful for The Chosen.
That is until Season 4, Episode 3. If you haven’t reached this episode yet, then please note spoilers follow…
Related articles
-
OpinionThe Archbishop of York is right to call out the BBC’s lack of religious literacy
The Archbishop of York has criticised the BBC for its “appalling lack of religious literacy”. Former head of religion at the BBC, Michael Wakelin agrees, but believes the remedy is not to be found in producing more religious programmes
-
Magazine Features100 books that changed the Church
With the help of a team of experts, data from publishers and listeners to Premier Christian Radio, we present your definitive guide to the titles which have most shaped the faith of the UK Church
-
Magazine FeaturesThe porn paradox
Millions of Christians live with a painful contradiction: believing one thing about porn while practising another. But the answer isn’t to heap on shame, says Martin Saunders. The Church has a better, more compassionate story to tell both performers and users
More from Opinion
-
OpinionWant your church to grow? Welcome children and let them be noisy
A church in Pennsylvania has sparked widespread debate after announcing its policy to welcome noisy children. “The sound of children in worship is not a distraction. It is evidence of life, growth and the future of the church,” its memo declared. Rev Ben Sleep explains how embracing a similar philosophy brought renewal to his own congregation on the south coast of England
-
OpinionThe UK’s Christian heritage is rapidly deteriorating. Pausing football games for Ramadan is just another example
From Ramadan breaks in football to halal food in workplaces, Islamic practices are becoming more visible in Britain today. Tim Dieppe says the real issue is not Muslim assertiveness but Christian retreat – and argues the Church must regain its boldness and courage to stand up for the truth of the Gospel
-
OpinionWhy UKIP’s ‘Walk with Jesus’ march is a cynical manipulation of our faith
As a new form of Christian Nationalism rises in the form of UKIP’s ‘Walk for Jesus’ marches, the Dean of Liverpool Cathedral is right to say he wants nothing to do with it, says Rev Dr Keith Brindle
- Issues
- Topics A-Z
- Writers A-Z
- © 2026 Premier Christianity
Site powered by Webvision Cloud