Churches are talking about mental health more than ever – but are we caring for those leading them?

pexels-cottonbro-6284481

While conversations about mental health have grown louder in the Church, Michael Tang argues it has neglected the structures of care needed to support those struggling. In doing so, he says, the Church may be settling for a form of ‘cheap healing’ that feels real but leaves deeper needs unaddressed

Generation Z is, by almost any measure, the most mentally distressed generation in living memory. NHS Digital’s 2023 survey found that the proportion of 17 to 19-year-olds in England with a probable mental disorder had more than doubled since 2017 — from one in ten to nearly one in four. Springtide Research Institute’s study of nearly 10,000 young people found that 61% believe the adults in their lives do not truly know how much they are struggling with their mental health. 

Those numbers should stop us in our tracks. A generation is sitting in our church buildings, perhaps raising their hands during worship and feeling largely unseen. That is the pastoral reality behind the cheerful talk about revival. If that is where we actually are, the question of what the church is actually doing about it is not a theological nicety. It is urgent. 

In March 2026, the Worship Leader Research project — led by academics at Belmont University and Baylor University— published what is believed to be the largest survey of worship leaders ever conducted in North America, with more than 3,600 participants. The headline finding is stark: only 3.4% of worship leaders rate their mental health as excellent, against approximately 29% of the general adult population. They are roughly eight times less likely to report excellent mental health than the people they lead. And 87% do not meet regularly with either a mental health professional or a spiritual director.